GeneralTop StoryTop StoryLatest News
Justice SK Kaul Clarifies Criticism of Ex-CJI Chandrachud
Sentiment: NeutralHigh Priority
What Happened?
Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul clarified that his criticism of former Chief Justice DY Chandrachud was focused on the judicial appointments process, not on Chandrachud's judicial record. He emphasized the need for the collegium to deliberate independently before consulting the government.
Key points
- Justice Kaul stated that the collegium should independently discuss candidates before consulting the government.
- He clarified that his remarks were not about Chandrachud's judicial capabilities but about the appointment process.
- Kaul's memoir, 'Without Fear or Favour', questions Chandrachud's handling of judicial appointments.
- He highlighted delays in filling vacancies in the Supreme Court and high courts.
- Kaul retired from the Supreme Court in December 2023 and served on the collegium under Chandrachud.
Key insights
- Kaul's remarks may influence future judicial appointment processes in India.
- The emphasis on independent deliberation could reshape the relationship between the judiciary and the executive.
- Delays in judicial appointments could undermine public confidence in the legal system.
Why it matters
This discussion highlights ongoing concerns about the independence of the judiciary in India.
Entities
Sanjay Kishan Kaul· PersonDY Chandrachud· PersonSupreme Court· OrganizationIndia· Country
Source
India Today
